Is the Israel Defense Forces a Moral Army?
IDF

The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) website describes its official doctrine of ethics, “The Spirit of the IDF,” as the army’s moral compass, which includes their three core values:

  • The defense of the state, its citizens, and residents;
  • Patriotism and loyalty to the state;
  • And human dignity regardless of race, faith, nationality, gender, or status.

While the Israel Defense Force’s stated ethos implies that it is a moral army, their actions offer contradictory evidence. The International Criminal Court has found that Israel commits war crimes against civilians using the power of its army. Haaretz and other reputable news sources have reported that the IDF does not intervene and even destroys evidence when Israeli settlers attack Palestinian civilians.

The following two cases of violence against civilians highlight how the IDF’s actions contradict its doctrine of ethics.

IDF Soldiers Destroy Video Evidence of Execution

In April 2019, 23-year-old Palestinian Muhammad ‘Abd Al Fatah stoned several Israeli-registered cars. Jewish settler Yehoshua Sherman fired his gun at ‘Abd Al Fatah from his vehicle. When unarmed ‘Abd Al Fatah took cover, Sherman and another Israeli moved closer to him and continued firing, first wounding him and then killing him as he lay on the ground bleeding.

Mondoweiss reported that IDF soldiers reacted to this murder by raiding two nearby businesses, confiscating their security cameras, and deleting footage of the crime. Meanwhile, the Israeli media falsely reported the murder as self-defense against a knife attack.

“The Spirit of the IDF” claims to value human dignity regardless of nationality or religion. However, a moral army would have intervened by breaking up the fighting and preserving human life instead of covering up an execution.


Children Hurt When Soldiers Hide Explosives

In August of 2020, on a Thursday afternoon, a seven-year-old boy was walking in the village with his family when he spotted an orange box covered in wires. “I wanted to pick it up and play with it,” he later told reporters. His relative picked up the box and shook it to inspect it, and the box exploded, wounding his face and hand.

Haaretz reported that the young Palestinian child had found one of many boxes of explosives and stun grenades planted by the IDF on open lands and hidden under stones, cloths, and weapons crates. The IDF claims it planted these boxes as a deterrence in areas “in which violent riots have regularly occurred for years.”

The boy and his family found three of these boxes along his village road. A relative said, “People live there, and children wander around. It’s lucky nothing worse happened.” The IDF planted explosives in a residential area to deter protests, without consideration for the civilians who would be injured.


Israel Defense Forces: A Moral Army or an Armed Gang?

B’Tselem, the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, commented on the IDF planting explosives: “This is how armed gangs operate, not a regular army. But the action reflects the spirit of the army’s commanders and the government, both of which send the message that Palestinian lives and limbs are fair game.”

Human rights organization Amnesty International made a public statement in May 2022 which declared that “Israeli authorities must end unlawful killings, willful injury, arbitrary arrests, torture, and other ill-treatment, persecution and collective punishment against Palestinians.”

Do these actions support an ethics of “universal moral values”?

Israeli Defense Forces

Israeli Veterans Break the Silence

Israeli soldiers are speaking out against the injustice military policies and actions they witnessed and enforced, including abuse toward Palestinians and the looting and destruction of property. Breaking the Silence, an organization of veteran soldiers who served in the Israeli military, have collected the testimonies of over 1,000 soldiers since 2004 who served in the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem with the intention of exposing the public to the grim daily realities of the occupation. 

One testimony from a Major in the Artillery Corps around 2015 referenced the way the Israeli educational system teaches students that Palestinians are enemies and should be feared. The soldier says: “I think that the argument about the most moral army in the world is a fig leaf, hiding what’s really happening.”

For example, the soldier describes the way a soldier will receive more punishment for eating lunch without notifying the army than a soldier who beats a Palestinian at a check point.

Can You Be the Moral Soldier?

Joel Carmel was raised in London, but his passion for defending Israel led him to join the IDF at 18 and become second lieutenant. He described growing up in a Zionist community that believed everyone was against the Jewish people of Israel, and it was his duty to defend Israel at all costs.

“I wanted to be the moral soldier. I believed I could be that soldier who gives the Palestinians good service — service with a smile,” he said. “Later I realized you could be as smiley as you like. You could give Palestinian children sweets, but ultimately, you control their lives with military power.”

His experience in the IDF exposed him to the daily abuses toward Palestinians, from the trampling of sacred holy sites to the firing of rubber bullets and live ammunition at unarmed civilians. Carmel added: “We are punishing people who haven’t done anything. Yes, there is terror, and some people are very threatening to us. But the occupation is a system of constant violence.”

A Response to “The Most Moral Army”

In 2018, the former editor-in-chief of The Jerusalem Post Jeff Barak published a response to the Israeli Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman’s statement that the IDF is “the most moral army in the world” calling for IDF sympathizers to get a reality check.

“Why is ‘the most moral army in the world’ automatically resorting to the use of live ammunition against unarmed demonstrators to quell such protests?” he asked, referencing the hundreds of Palestinian demonstrators wounded by live fire over less than one month. “We should show the maturity to honestly examine ourselves in the mirror.”


Do you think the “World’s Most Moral Army” acts immorally?

Visit the Promised Land Museum to learn more about Israel-Palestine from a Jewish perspective.


Latest Posts

Seth Morrison: Being on the Side of Peace

Seth Morrison: Being on the Side of Peace

Retired marketer Seth Morrison used to support and fund Zionist organizations. Now, he is an activist who boycotts them in support of the Palestinian right to return. As a liberal Jew from Long Island who grew up with a desire to help fix the world’s problems,...

read more
What Happened to Shireen Abu Akleh?

What Happened to Shireen Abu Akleh?

The Tragic Killing of a Palestinian-American Journalist On the morning of May 11, 2022, American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh went to the occupied West Bank town of Jenin with other journalists to film an Israeli military raid. Without warning, Israeli forces shot her...

read more
Dispelling Lies about Palestine

Dispelling Lies about Palestine

John Minto’s 2020 David Wakim Memorial Lecture The David Wakim Memorial Lecture, a Pax Christi event, took place in September 2020. Pax Christi International is a Catholic peace movement with 120 member organizations worldwide. Its goals are to support peace,...

read more
A Voice of Reason in the Israel-Palestine Conflict

A Voice of Reason in the Israel-Palestine Conflict

U.S. Representative Marc Pocan Visits the West Bank During his time in Congress, U.S. representative Marc Pocan has been vocal about the Israel-Palestine conflict. In June 2017, he was the only congressional sponsor of a briefing on Capitol Hill about “life for...

read more
Dispelling Myths about Israel

Dispelling Myths about Israel

Ten Myths about Israel: A Book Review "Historical disinformation, even of the most recent past, can do tremendous harm," Israeli historian and University of Exeter professor Ilan Pappé writes in his latest book, Ten Myths About Israel, published by Verso Books in...

read more
Gabor Maté and Justifying Violence

Gabor Maté and Justifying Violence

In his book, In the Realm of Hungry Ghosts: Close Encounters with Addiction, Dr.Gabor Maté writes that “no society can understand itself without looking at its shadow side.” Hungarian-Canadian physician Gabor Maté is a Holocaust survivor, addiction expert, speaker,...

read more
Movies

Movies

Documentary films serve as non-fictional motion-picture historical records intended to document reality in the way events truly happened. These films tell important and often unknown stories that bring a greater awareness to a wider audience. These films are some of...

read more
Artifacts

Artifacts

As we seek to understand the depth and breadth of a conflict, it’s important to look back to the cultural artifacts. Whether ancient or current, scholarly or commonplace, these items offer us an insight into past technological processes, economic development, and...

read more
Infographics & Maps

Infographics & Maps

From historical to present-day maps of Israel and Palestinian territories and infographics that show history in a visual way, these tools will help us visualize the conditions of occupation and how real people are affected daily with struggles and ongoing hardships....

read more
Photos

Photos

They say a picture says 1,000 words. We have searched through documents, research, historical artifacts, and more to find the photos that tell the story of the Israeli and Palestinian land and people. From pre-conflict days all the way to our current times, we...

read more
Jerusalem